REMEMBERING THE DEAD

naming-the-dead.JPG

Earlier this week I had a meeting with InSwindon – the Town Centre management company – about the possibility of Swindon Stop the War Coalition participating in a ceremony that they are organising for Wharf Green on Armistice day, 11th November.

Their desire is to have a ceremony to commemorate the dead of all wars, and those who die in service, and keep it “non-political”, and they are having exploratory talks with all possible stakeholders.

Obviously the Army are quite keen. InSwindon are also keen to include – for example – the Fire Brigade and Ambulance Service.

By coincidence, we had recently discussed at our Stop the War organising meeting what we were going to do to mark the milestone 300th British service death in both Iraq and Afghanistan, and the feeling of the meeting was that we need to be careful to keep some political edge, that we are not just commemorating the dead, we are also making a political point that the war is wrong.

On this basis, I said at the meeting with InSwindon, that if we were to participate it would be on the basis of representing the civilian deaths of war as well as the military, and also making it clear that we also commemorated the war deaths of Iraqis and Afghans, and all other nations. On this basis we could not participate in or endorse in any way a service that was built around the British armed forces and a bugler playing the Last Post, for example. I argued that this would be an inherently political ceremony that suggests rallying around the flag to support “our boys” uncritically.

It will be interesting to see what happens, because we do represent a significant tranche of public opinion, and the Swindon Advertiser will certainly ask out view of the event, so we may be able to shape the commemoration. If we do find a way of including in the event a commemoration of the Irai and Afghan war dead, that would be a significant achievement.

On the other hand I find it hard to imagine any form of ceremony that would be acceptable to both the Stop the War Coalition, and the British Army!

The photo shows the recent ceremony we had in Swindon to mark the 100th British casualty in Afghanistan, you can read more about it at Socialist Unity blog.

Advertisements

2 responses to “REMEMBERING THE DEAD

  1. Andy, you said:

    On this basis we could not participate in or endorse in any way a service that was built around the British armed forces and a bugler playing the Last Post, for example. I argued that this would be an inherently political ceremony that suggests rallying around the flag to support “our boys” uncritically.

    If, as you suggest, you can ‘shape’ the ceremony, aren’t you then dictating to attendees which dead they must commemorate?

    If you can’t endorse the ceremony ‘as is’ then don’t attend it…. it’s a public place so why not hold an alternative commemoration ceremony and commemorate whoever you wish, in the manner you wish and leave others free to do exactly the same?

  2. andyinswindon

    Geoff

    We have been consulted as possible stake holders in a rememberance ceremony, to put forward our angle. Remember the proposed ceremony is being organised by InSwindon on the basis of it being as non-political as possible.

    If the Army wish to have a ceremony for British service deaths then they can go ahead – they already have Rememberence sunday, and the wreath laying at the cenotaph for that BTW.

    But if this event is to be more inclusive, and also reflect the opinions of those Swindonians who wish to commemorate the dead without seeming to give implicit political support to the current wars, then InSwindon are right to try to fainf a middle way.

    The point here of course is that there is no ceremony “as is” – there are currently only discussions about what sort of ceremnoy there mighe be.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s